Resolved · opened Aug 25, 2026, 10:01 AM EDT
Should the Colorado Rockies keep Jake McCarthy in the leadoff spot tonight?
Jake McCarthyColorado Rockies
Colorado Rockies01 / Make the call
The choices, as published.
Why Posterior is asking
Jake McCarthy batted leadoff for the Colorado Rockies on 2026-08-24. Tonight the Colorado Rockies play the Washington Nationals. This asks what the club should do — the receipt records what it did.
Keep Jake McCarthy leading off
Bat someone else leadoff
Results held until at least 25 qualified respondents — currently —
Community arguments
Community content — not Posterior evidence. One argument per voter, arguing their own call; ratings score argument quality, never agreement.
Voting is closed — the discussion is frozen as it stood.
No arguments were posted on this question.
02 / The evidence
The evidence, frozen at publish.
MLB Stats API boxscore
Jake McCarthy batted leadoff for the Colorado Rockies on 2026-08-24 (MLB boxscore, gamePk 822695).
Frozen Aug 25, 2026, 10:00 AM EDT
03 / Reality
What actually happened.
Outcome · Aug 26, 2026, 1:35 AM EDT
Colorado Rockies kept Jake McCarthy in the leadoff spot.
Source: statsapi:lineups:2026-08-25:gamePk:822693